Pessimistic induction is an argument that points to the history of science and the tendency for accepted ideas to change with time. This is typically used as an argument against scientific realism. For example, a scientific realist might say that a pesticide isn't a health concern because it was studied and deemed reasonably safe by a government study. Pessimistic induction could be used to point out that a particular government has a history of approving chemicals as safe that were revealed to cause health issues decades later.
Half-Life of Knowledge
Every subject, profession and industry goes through a process of knowledge discovery that results in a turnover of ideas known as the half-life of knowledge. Some ideas accepted today will become obsolete or be disproven with time. Pessimistic induction points to the fact that historically speaking, decisions based on well-accepted knowledge would often be wrong. If you made all of your decisions based on complete faith in science in the year 1900, some of your decisions would be off.
Practical Considerations
It is impractical to distrust all knowledge on the assumption that the future will disprove it. As such, pessimistic induction isn't typically considered a strong or insightful argument. Nevertheless, it may have some value in supporting ideas such as the precautionary principle.
Cookies help us deliver our services. You have choices regarding these cookies. Please visit our privacy policy, cookie policy and consent tool to learn more.
Copyright 2002-2026 Simplicable. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, redistributed or translated. Report violations here.